Fed Rate Cuts 2025: Why Borrowing Costs Don’t Always Drop

Sep 29, 2025

When the Federal Reserve lowers interest rates, the headline often suggests relief is on the way for borrowers with lower borrowing costs. In some cases, that’s true. Short-term borrowing costs like adjustable-rate loans, personal lines of credit, and certain business loans may drop rather quickly. But that’s not always the case. And longer-term loans may catch borrowers by surprise as 30-year mortgages don’t always decline with Fed policy. Understanding why can help you make better financial decisions.

Treasury Yields and Long-Term Loans

For mortgages and other fixed long-term loans, the Fed’s short-term rate is only part of the story. Rates on products like 30-year mortgages are more closely tied to the 10-year U.S. Treasury yield, which reflects investor expectations for inflation, government debt levels, and global demand for U.S. bonds. If Treasury yields remain elevated, mortgage rates may stay stubbornly high even when the Fed is cutting. In fact, spreads between mortgage rates and Treasuries can widen when investors demand more compensation for risk, further limiting relief for homebuyers.

 

Short-Term Loans: Credit Cards and Auto Financing

Credit cards and auto loans are influenced more directly by the Fed’s moves, but that doesn’t mean borrowers can see big drops. Credit card APRs, for example, are tied to the prime rate (which moves with the Fed funds rate), yet banks layer on large risk premiums. That means even if the Fed trims rates, consumers may only see small reductions. While auto loans may also drop along with the Fed decision, lenders also need to account for credit risk, vehicle values, and consumer demand.

 

Why Rates May Stay Higher Anyway

Beyond benchmarks, lenders set rates based on broader funding costs and market conditions. The difference between the borrower’s rate and a benchmark rate (a.k.a the spread) often widens when markets are uncertain or when lenders perceive higher risks, which can keep borrowing costs elevated even if the Fed cuts its policy rate. Put simply: a Fed cut lowers one part of the borrowing equation, but credit risk, regulatory costs, and investor appetite all affect the final rate consumers see.

 

What Borrowers Should Consider

For consumers, don’t assume a Fed rate cut automatically lowers your borrowing costs, but if it does you may not want to “look a gift horse in the mouth” so-to-speak. Mortgage rates may stay tied to stubbornly high Treasury yields, while credit card APRs remain elevated because of bank pricing. Auto loans and personal loans may ease slightly, but they won’t drop to the levels many remember from the recent past. When using credit, especially for large purchases, the best strategy is to think about how borrowing costs impact your overall financial plan. And when you feel comfortable with that continue to monitor rates and shop for competitive offers to be ready to lock in favorable terms when they appear.

— More —

Chasing Market Highs? – Behavioral Finance at Work

Chasing Market Highs? – Behavioral Finance at Work

When markets reach record highs, it’s natural to feel excitement and optimism. News headlines celebrate these highs again-and-again, and suddenly the fear of missing out (FOMO) sets in. This is often called herd behavior, where we follow the crowd rather than our own...

A Financial Advisor’s Guide to Teaching Teens Smart Money Habits

A Financial Advisor’s Guide to Teaching Teens Smart Money Habits

This blog post, guest-authored by Envest summer intern Charlotte Ward, is the first in a two-part series on building financial literacy in young adults. Part 2 will tackle launching youth into full financial independence. When teens start earning money, whether from...

Social Security: Benefits, Myths, and Key Features

Social Security: Benefits, Myths, and Key Features

Established in 1935, Social Security is a critical part of retirement planning for nearly 90 years. Funded by payroll taxes, this program provides retirement, survivor, and disability benefits. Today, Social Security operates through two main components: (1) ongoing...

Understanding Credit Reports and Scores: Why They Matter

Understanding Credit Reports and Scores: Why They Matter

Your credit report and credit score are key indicators of your financial health. A credit report is a detailed record of your credit history, including accounts, payment history, and inquiries from lenders. Your credit score, on the other hand, is a numerical...

Book an Introductory Meeting Today

Start your ESG/SRI journey. Schedule a no-obligation, 15-minute complimentary call to learn more about our approach and how it may fit with your goals.

Top